Car Consignment in Newmarket | Sell Your Car Hassle Free

Looking to sell your used car in Newmarket or anywhere in Ontario? Carco’s car consignment program helps you get more money without the stress. We handle the marketing, buyer screening, and paperwork for you.

Why Sell with Carco?

Other Dealers

Payment can take 20 days
Low trade-in offers
Haggling guaranteed
Lengthy inspections
Pushy upselling tactics
Requires vehicle prep

Get top market value
We handle everything
Visible to buyers across Ontario
No upfront cost
We handle test drives & paperwork
Your car your terms

Private Buyers

Time-consuming and risky
Insecure payments & fraud risk
Haggling guaranteed
No-shows
Requires vehicle prep
Be ready to wait

Learn about our Consignment Program

CarCosignment in 3 Steps

Submit Your Car Details

Start by filling out our quick consignment form. It only takes 2 minutes.

Drop Off or Keep Driving

Leave your car with us in Newmarket or keep using it while we market it for you.

Approve Offer & Get Paid

We’ll present verified offers. Accept one and get paid same-day. It’s that easy.

Get More Details

How You Get Paid

We offer flexible payment options to suit your needs. Whether you prefer a certified cheque, direct deposit, or bank draft, we work with you to ensure a smooth and secure transaction.

Direct Deposit

Securely receive funds straight into your bank account. Most deposits complete within 24 hours after your car is sold.

Certified Cheque

Prefer a physical payment? We'll issue a certified cheque from a trusted Canadian bank for fast deposit or cashing.

Bank Draft

Choose a secure bank draft payment, ideal for sellers who want guaranteed funds with minimal risk.

₿

Cryptocurrency

Soon, you'll be able to receive payment in popular cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin or Ethereum. A modern option for sellers who prefer digital assets.

No delays. No surprises. Carco ensures fast payouts and peace of mind for every seller in Newmarket and across Ontario.

What Ontario Drivers Are Saying

"I sold my Civic through Carco in just 6 days. The process was smooth and the team in Newmarket was super helpful."

John M. – 2018 Honda Civic

"Traded in my RAV4 and the offer was better than dealerships. Everything was done locally and quickly."

Samantha T. – 2020 Toyota RAV4

"Consigning my BMW with Carco got me thousands more than trade-in offers. Highly recommended in Ontario."

Raj P. – 2016 BMW 3 Series

Serving Newmarket & All of Ontario

Carco is based in Newmarket, Ontario — but we work with sellers across the province. Whether you are in Toronto, Ottawa, Barrie, or anywhere in between, we offer convenient vehicle pickup and secure processing. Prefer to drop off? Visit us in Newmarket for priority consignment.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is car consignment and how does it work?

Car consignment allows you to sell your vehicle through Carco without dealing with the hassle of private listings or low trade-in offers. You keep ownership while we professionally market, show, and sell your vehicle for top dollar. Once it sells, we handle the paperwork and pay you the agreed amount minus our flat service fee.

Why consign my car instead of selling it myself?

Consigning your car with Carco means less time wasted, no strangers at your home, and no need to negotiate with buyers. We attract more serious buyers, handle all calls and appointments, and ensure your car is showcased professionally, helping you get more money without the stress.

How much more can I make with consignment?

On average, our consignment clients earn 10 to 30% more than they would from a trade-in or wholesale offer. By listing your vehicle at a competitive retail price and marketing it across multiple platforms, we ensure it gets maximum exposure and top value.

Is there a cost to list my vehicle on consignment?

No upfront costs. We only charge a flat service fee once your vehicle sells. If it doesn’t sell, you don’t pay a thing. Our goal is to get you the highest return possible, and we don’t profit unless you do.

How long does it take to sell a consigned vehicle?

Most vehicles listed on consignment sell within 1 to 3 weeks, depending on condition, demand, and market price. We provide regular updates and can adjust the listing strategy if needed.

Do I need to leave my vehicle with Carco?

We recommend leaving your car at our secure Newmarket facility for faster sales and buyer convenience. However, if you prefer to keep driving it, we can still list it with mileage tracking and appointment-based viewings.

What documents do I need to consign my car?

You'll need your vehicle ownership, a valid photo ID, and any lien or loan details (if applicable). We’ll help with any additional paperwork to ensure a smooth and legal sale.

Can I cancel the consignment if I change my mind?

Yes, you can cancel the consignment agreement at any time before a sale is finalized. There are no penalties or hidden fees if you choose to withdraw your vehicle from the program.

Is the consignment program only for Newmarket residents?

Not at all! While our hub is in Newmarket, we offer pickup services across Ontario. If you're nearby, you’re welcome to drop off the vehicle, otherwise, we’ll help coordinate logistics to bring it in for listing.

What kinds of vehicles are accepted for consignment?

We accept most used vehicles in good condition cars, SUVs, trucks, and even specialty vehicles. If your car has low mileage, a clean title, and decent service history, it’s likely eligible. We’ll assess it and let you know if it’s a good fit.